
Scroll through any online marketplace today and you’ll almost certainly spot a product photo that looks a little too perfect. The lighting is flawless, the background is spotless, and something about the whole image feels just slightly off, like a dream you can’t quite place. There’s a good chance it was generated or touched up by AI, and you’re far from the only one wondering whether that’s a problem.

It’s a fair thing to wonder about. A recent survey found that a large majority of shoppers, roughly seven in ten, admit they feel uneasy when they suspect a product photo was created or heavily edited by artificial intelligence rather than taken with an actual camera. That unease makes complete sense. When you’re buying something secondhand, whether it’s a phone, a sofa, or a stroller, the photo is often the only real evidence you have of what you’re actually getting.

Here’s the more encouraging part of that same story, though. Interestingly, when sellers are upfront about AI involvement, trust doesn’t drop, it actually climbs. A notable share of online shoppers, close to seven in ten, say they’re more likely to trust a listing when the seller clearly discloses that a photo was AI-assisted, rather than trying to quietly pass it off as an untouched original. Honesty, it turns out, beats polish every single time.
This shift hasn’t gone unnoticed by the platforms themselves either. Toward the end of last year, Google updated its product listing policies to require that whatever appears in a photo must genuinely be the item up for sale. No swapping in a manufacturer’s glossy stock image when your actual couch has a small stain on one cushion, and no using an AI tool to erase a scratch that a buyer will absolutely notice the moment they pick the item up in person.

So how do you actually tell the difference when you’re browsing listings yourself? A few small habits go a long way. Look closely at backgrounds first, since AI-generated or AI-cleaned images sometimes produce edges that are just a touch too smooth, or shadows that fall in a direction that doesn’t quite match the light source in the rest of the photo. Zoom in on fine details too, especially text, stitching, or small logos, since these are places where AI tools still tend to stumble and produce slightly warped or blurry results. And don’t be shy about simply asking the seller for one more photo taken right there in the moment, ideally holding today’s newspaper or a handwritten note beside the item. A genuine seller will happily snap one; someone hiding something usually hesitates.

If you’re the one selling something on Shoofi, the lesson here works in your favor too. A clear, honest photo taken with your own phone, even if the lighting isn’t studio-perfect, tends to build more trust than an artificially polished image ever could. Buyers aren’t looking for perfection. They’re looking for confidence that what they see is genuinely what they’ll get delivered to their door.

AI tools aren’t the enemy here, and there’s nothing wrong with using one to brighten a dim photo or straighten a crooked angle. The real line worth drawing is between enhancing a real photo and inventing one that doesn’t reflect reality. Keep that distinction in mind, whether you’re buying or selling, and the whole experience becomes a lot less stressful for everyone involved.
One last thought worth keeping in your back pocket: trust on a marketplace is built slowly, one good transaction at a time, and it can be undone quickly by a single misleading photo. Whether you’re the buyer squinting at a listing or the seller framing your next shot, a little bit of transparency about how a photo was made goes further than most people expect.