
If you make things by hand, you know the awkward moment when someone asks how much it costs. You hesitate, picture the cheapest factory version and say a number that’s lower than you meant. Gift season is approaching, which means more people are looking for something with a story behind it, and it’s the perfect moment to price your work in a way that’s fair to you and to the buyer.
Start with the simplest part, which is materials. Add up everything that goes into a piece, including the small items people forget, like ribbon, thread, glue, wicks, packaging and the tape that holds the box closed. Divide the cost of larger supplies across the number of items they make, so you know what each piece truly costs. Most makers are surprised by how high this number is once they stop guessing.

Then comes your time, which is the part that gets underpriced the most. Estimate how many hours a piece takes, including preparation, cleaning up, photographing and messaging with the buyer. Decide on an hourly figure you’d be happy to earn, even a modest one, and multiply it. If the final price feels too high, the answer is rarely to work for nothing. It’s usually to simplify the design, speed up a step or find the buyers who value the work.
Next, add the small costs of running the whole thing. Listing time, delivery, replacing tools, a bit of margin for the pieces that don’t turn out perfectly. A simple way to cover these without a complicated spreadsheet is to add a modest percentage on top of materials and time. It’s not greedy. It’s what keeps you making things next month instead of burning out.

Once you have a figure, compare it with similar handmade work, not factory products. A mass-produced candle and a hand-poured one with a custom scent are different things, and buyers know it. What they need from you is a reason, so tell them. Mention the materials, the time and what makes the piece yours. A sentence such as “hand-poured in small batches, takes two days to cure” explains the price better than any discount ever could.

Gift season rewards bundles. A set of three small pieces, a matching card and a nicely wrapped box can sell for more than the items would separately, because you’re also selling the effort of choosing. Offer a simple ready-to-give option, and be clear about ordering deadlines so buyers can plan. Busy people love knowing exactly when something will arrive.

For custom orders, protect yourself. Agree on the design and the price before you start, and ask for a small deposit if the materials are expensive. Say how many changes are included and what happens if the buyer wants more. This isn’t unfriendly. Clear terms prevent arguments and tell buyers you take your work seriously.

Photos do a lot of the selling, so show the piece in good daylight, with a hand or a familiar object for scale, and add a close-up of the detail you’re proudest of. Describe the size, the materials and how to care for it. When people can see the quality, a fair price feels natural. Discounting should be a deliberate choice, not a reflex when someone says it’s a bit much.

Delivery deserves a line in your price too. Decide whether you offer pickup, meeting points or a courier, and be clear about who pays and when. A well-wrapped parcel with a small handwritten note costs very little, but it’s what people remember, and it’s often what turns a first-time buyer into someone who tells their friends about you.
It’s fine to adjust over time. Start with a price that covers your costs and respects your time, watch how people respond, and raise it when your pieces sell quickly or you have a waiting list. Underselling teaches buyers that your work is cheap, and that’s difficult to undo. Fair pricing teaches them it’s worth waiting for, and those are the customers who come back every season.